The Lost Art of Video Game Critique
Gred Glintstone Gred Glintstone
7.02K subscribers
255,269 views
13K

 Published On Oct 6, 2024

This video is a response to ‪@JosephAndersonChannel‬ and ‪@feebleking21‬. It is a critique of their critiques. ‪@Matthewmatosis‬ is also featured heavily but he is not the focus of the video. The focus of the video is the style of critique that both Joseph Anderson and Feeble King affect, and the accusations of toxicity (both negative and positive) that they recently made in their respective Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree critiques.

Footage:

Joseph Anderson    • Subjectivity is Implied  
Joseph Anderson    • Dark Souls Critique - Part One  
Joseph Anderson    • Dark Souls Critique - Part Three  
Joseph Anderson    • Dark Souls Critique - Part Five  
Joseph Anderson    • Elden Ring - A Shattered Masterpiece  
Joseph Anderson    • Phase Two (Elden Ring - Shadow of the...  
Joseph Anderson    • Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc - Sp...  
Feeble King    • The Elden Ring Critique - Hard is the...  
Feeble King    • In Defense of Elden Ring Boss Design ...  
Feeble King    • Shadow of the Erdtree Critique - From...  
Feeble King    • Bloodborne is BETTER at Level 4!  
Feeble King    • Shadow of the Erdtree is Still Very D...  
Matthewmatosis    • Dark Souls 2 Critique  
Matthewmatosis    • The Lost Soul Arts of Demon's Souls  
TheDeModcracy    • Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree Bos...  
TheDeModcracy    • So I Made a Bad Elden Ring Video...  
BonfireVN    • St. Trina - Closer Look  
TheTalentlessWriter    • The Myth of Sisyphus Is Weird Af  
newtrollclub    • 3d animation - SISYPHUS  
Vaulty    • 5 Hardest Grinds in Classic WoW  
Signs of kelani    • 8 Most Efficient Ways To Farm Artifac...  
K11er six    • TOP 10 BEST Item Farms in Borderlands...  
Reactionreboot    • Lets Player's Reaction To The Command...  
Kai Cenat Live    • I FINALLY BEAT RADAHN  
Shirrako    • Dark Souls Remastered - Manus, Father...  
Boss Fight Database    • Bloodborne: Blood-starved Beast Boss ...  
Sweeping Limelight Gaming    • Elden Ring - Starscurge Radahn Twitch...  
Solid_jj    • The Beautiful Simplicity of Rhino  
Boss Fight Database    • God of War 3 Remastered: Cronos Boss ...  
Sweet_mj    • DMC3 - guitar scene  
Teuber    • The best cutscene in any game  
Warner Bros. Pictures    • Edge of Tomorrow - Official Trailer 1...  
Reason    • Malenia, All Hit Run  
Backslash    • Elden Ring DLC - Promised Consort Rad...  
Rabbidluigi    • EVERY Bethesda Game Ranked from Worst...  
Vivan    • Elden Ring  - Mohg, Lord of Blood - b...  
옹발이 ONGBAL    • Elden Ring - Lvl1 Wretch VS Mohg, Lor...  
HemlocksVirtue    • Elden Ring - Radagon LEVEL 1 NO UPGRA...  
IGN    • 7 Things to Do First in Sekiro: Shado...  
Chasethebro    • Elden Ring: Warhawk's Talon Has An Am...  
Shen Rii    • Demon's Souls - Firebomb VS Phalanx  
Basileous    • Super Mario Bros (NES) Level 1-1  
Kingboo97    • Super Mario Maker 2 - 31/1,040,000 Ja...  
Mashal No Commentary    • Call of Duty Warzone 3 Solo SNIPER Ga...  
CGInferno    • Elden Ring Shadow of The Erdtree - Ne...  
James Ferris    • Demon's Souls intro HD  
BANDAI NAMCO Entertainment    • Dark Souls III - Opening Cinematic Tr...  
InStarsWeTrust    • Bloodborne™ Opening  Cinematic  
Gamespot    • Elden Ring Cinematic Trailer | Game A...  
Boss Fight Database    • Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice - Opening C...  
BANDAI NAMCO Europe    • ELDEN RING Shadow of the Erdtree | St...  
Brunoborne    • Elden Ring - Messmer The Impaler Boss...  
Jordien    • Elden Ring Patch 1.12: We can use Tor...  
EFISHTV    • Ryu vs Akuma (Hardest AI) - Street Fi...  

Sources:

https://www.eurogamer.net/souls-survivor
http://soulslore.wikidot.com/das1-var...
https://www.eurogamer.net/tough-love-...
https://www.wired.com/story/dark-soul...
https://www.bloodborne-wiki.com/2017/...
  / no-dark-souls-does-not-need-an-easy-mode  
https://www.gamesradar.com/games/acti...
https://www.thegamer.com/elden-ring-c...

Timestamps:

0:00 Intro
2:22 You Are Not Immune
21:48 The Role of the Critic
48:49 One Must Imagine the Tarnished Happy
1:09:13 The Death of Miyazaki
1:22:30 Why Don't You Want Games to be Good?
1:44:51 The Explosion
1:57:52 I Am Not Immune

#eldenring #josephanderson #feebleking #matthewmatosis #critique #videoessay

show more

Share/Embed